Countdown to Fall: Five Science Fiction and Fantasy Shows Facing Big Question Marks This Year
August 26, 2009 at 11:04 am | In Articles, John J. Joex, Previews | 1 CommentTags: Eastwick, Heroes, Stargate Universe, V, Vampire Diaries
By John J. Joex
The Fall 2009 season is almost upon us bringing us sixteen shows in the Science Fiction and Fantasy vein, ten returning series and six new entries including AMC’s The Prisoner mini-series (see our Fall Preview for more information on each these shows). That’s quite a lot of television viewing, even if you only plan on watching half of those shows on a regular basis. Last week I gave my list of five must-watch shows for the upcoming season. Now it’s time to take a look at five shows facing some pretty big question marks as they prepare for their Fall bow. This includes one returning show that faces the task of winning back fans and four new shows that I question whether it is really worth our time to commit to watching on a weekly basis.
Heroes (NBC, Returns September 21st)– How much does this one have left in the tank? After a stellar first season (weakened a bit by an anti-climatic finale, though) this show has struggled through its two subsequent seasons. And this has lead to a significant drop off in viewership as the series tumbled down to only around six million viewers by the end of last season. The creative team just cannot seem to reconnect with what made the show great early on and the show has continued to deliver erratic episodes. Bryan Fuller returned to the series late last season, sparking some sense of hope among fans, but he quickly abandoned ship. Allegedly that was planned all along, but I would much rather see his name in the credits. So we have to ask at what does the future hold for this show? How many times can they kill of characters to only have them come back to life again (and we already know Tracy is coming back)? How many times can the time travel to reset the timeline? How many more characters can they throw at us? The show has just become tired and has to rediscover itself pretty quickly otherwise NBC (who remained patient with it last year) will most likely show it the door. And there is no one in the real world who can time travel and save it.
V (ABC, Debuts November 3rd) – Those who remember the original mini-series know that it was quite an event when it aired in 1983 giving us one of the biggest special effects laden spectacles ever to be seen on television up to that point. And the follow up mini-series was kind of fun as well. But by the time they had turned this into a weekly series, they seemed to be scraping the bottom of the barrel. Now ABC will put us through the whole cycle again, but without the mini-series kick-off. My whole problem with V, which became a factor from the second mini-series on (spoilers to follow), is that once the humans found out that the aliens were actually just lizards wearing costumes, what was the point for them to keep the disguises on? Those things must have been incredibly uncomfortable, but they continued to wear them throughout the run of the series. I was hoping that the new series would dispense with that and use some sort of transformation gimmick instead, but the preview trailer suggests not. This was something I could just never get past in the original version and will apparently have to deal with in the remake. I will definitely tune in to see how the new version looks, but I am hoping it diverges significantly from where the original went after the initial mini-series.
Stargate: Universe (SyFy, Debuts October 2nd) – Trapped on a starship at the far side of the galaxy with no way home, Captain Janeway and her crew must struggle to survive with only their wits in Delta Quadrant . . . oh wait. Wrong franchise! But still, it seems like we have the same story. Stargate: Universe follows the exploits of a team who, after boarding an ancient starship, get flung off into deep space and must try to find their way back to Earth. I have never been a huge fan of the Stargate franchise to begin with, so seeing that this is following the path of that other well know “Star” franchise does not really entice me into watching the series. Still, I admit that the previous two Stargate incarnations have been watchable and have delivered consistently competent episodes, so I will at least take a peek at the early episodes of this show.
Eastwick (ABC, Debuts September 23rd) – Based on John Updike’s novel The Witches of Eastwick which also spawned the film starring Jack Nicholson, this series follows three women with magical powers who find that their abilities increase when a devilish visitor comes to town. I admit that the preview trailer peaked my interest in this a bit, but ultimately I wonder if this one will just be Charmed for an older crowd. The fact that this concept has been tried twice before on television and resulted in two failed pilots for both NBC and FOX does not bode well for Eastwick’s future. And ABC has not had a good track record recently in the Science Fiction and Fantasy realm beyond Lost for the last few years (though we have to give them credit for continuing to try). At this point, I’m thinking this will be one of the early casualties for the coming Fall season.
Vampire Diaries (CW, Debuts September 10th) – Oh my god! This series is going to be just the coolest! I mean I have all the books and Paul Wesley is just so dreamy , and . . . Oh wait. I’m not a fourteen year old girl. So maybe I’m not the demographic they are shooting for. This series is adapted from L.J. Smith’s book series of the same name and essentially gives us Twilight for the small screen. In fact, reading the descriptions of the Vampire Diaries novels, I can barely distinguish them from what I know about the Twilight series. But I guess that just shows how far off the mark I am from that target audience. I actually think that this one could be a hit for the CW (God knows they need one), but unlike Supernatural, which this will lead into, I doubt this will attract many viewers beyond its core demographic. They have to just hope that there are enough girls in that pre-teen to young teen range that will keep coming back for more of this.
Previous: Five Science Fiction and Fantasy Shows You Have to Tune in For
Next: We Tell All! Spoilers for the Fall Shows
Shop Science Fiction and Fantasy at the Axiom’s Edge Bazaar:
Countdown to Fall: Five Science Fiction and Fantasy Shows You Have to Tune in For
August 20, 2009 at 6:35 am | In Articles, John J. Joex, Previews | 3 CommentsTags: Dollhouse, Flash Forward, Fringe, Supernatural, The Prisoner
By John J. Joex
The upcoming Fall season will bring us sixteen shows in the Science Fiction and Fantasy vein, ten returning series and six new entries including AMC’s The Prisoner mini-series (see our Fall Preview for more information on each these shows). That’s quite a commitment of television viewing if you plan on catching all of them, and if so you’d better clear your schedule for the next few months and prep your DVR. Of course most people just don’t have the time to watch that much television, so I decided to weigh in with some advice on the must watch events for the upcoming Fall. Because, do you really need to tune in for a show like Vampire Diaries (OMG, only if you are female and under 15!) or yet another rehash of a long forgotten television series like V? True, the broadcast networks and cable channels are giving us a lot more to choose from in the Science Fiction and Fantasy realm these days, but how much is really worth our time? Well in answer to that, here’s the five shows that I definitely think should make it to the top of your viewing list for the coming months. Not that you shouldn’t check out the other shows, just make sure that you don’t miss these (listed in order of debut/return date).
(Note: I am only considering the shows that will bow in the Fall which excludes mid-season entries like Lost, Chuck, and Day One. I will focus on those shows as we get closer to the new year.)
Supernatural (CW, Returns September 10th) – How can you not tune in when all Hell is about to break loose. Literally. The Season 4 finale left Sam and Dean as they were about to face off with Lucifer himself! And even though I don’t believe that Season 5 will really give us Hell on Earth, I have become quite addicted to this show about two brothers doing battle with malevolent supernatural forces, and I expect it to continue to deliver some good stories. And hey, series creator Eric Kripke wants this to be the show’s last season (the CW probably has other plans, though), so no telling what could happen in the coming year.
Fringe (FOX, Returns September 17th) – Yeah, I know. I complained about this show quite regularly last season. But I also acknowledged that when the show hit on all cylinders it really soared. And Fringe definitely went out on a strong note last season (Olivia in a parallel universe face to face with William Bell), so you have to at least tune in for the resolution. And who wants to miss out Leonard Nimoy’s return to Science Fiction television?
Dollhouse (FOX, Returns September 18th) – Many people grumbled that this series got off to an uneven start last season, but few deny that it went out on a really strong note. I actually enjoyed it all the way through and look forward to its second season which sprang from a miracle renewal. Joss Whedon’s show about people who take on different personalities for each new mission gave us something new and challenging last season in the land of rehashes. And the fact that definite personas started to emerge for Echo and the other actives despite the fact that they changed personalities each week speaks to how well the creative team developed the stories and characters. Plus, all Whedon fans know that his shows continue to improve with age.
FlashForward (ABC, Debuts September 24th) – This series, based on the Robert J. Sawyer novel of the same name, chronicles the events after the entire world blacks our for two minutes and seventeen seconds and sees visions of the future during that time. It is being billed as the next Lost and what I have seen so far looks pretty intriguing. The producers have promised to answer many of the questions posed by the first season finale (covering their bases in the case of cancellation) but also claim to have enough story ideas to carry them through several seasons. Of the new entries for the Fall, this definitely looks like the strongest one and hopefully it will pick up the torch from its network neighbor Lost which will make its exit later in the season.
The Prisoner (AMC, Debuts in November) – What can you say about the original version of The Prisoner? It was a classic of Science Fiction, a bold triumph for the medium of television, and its initial accomplishment can probably never be rivaled. That, of course, will not stop AMC from trying. With a six-episode mini-series, the cable channel plans to re-imagine Patrick McGoohan’s classic series. When I first heard about this, I said “No way!” But I have to admit they have brought in some impressive talent on the project (including James Caviezel as Number 6 and Sir Ian McKellen as Number 2), and the preview trailer looks intriguing. They seem to be taking the concept in a very different direction from the original and might just pull it off. In any case, you know that you have to tune in just to see what happens!
Next: Five Shows Facing Big Questions Marks
Previous: Does Heroes Suck? Can it Be Fixed? Does Anybody Care Anymore?
Shop Science Fiction and Fantasy at the Axiom’s Edge Bazaar:
Ninja/Power Ranger/Spider-Man? Say What?
August 14, 2009 at 7:46 am | In Articles, John J. Joex | 2 CommentsTags: Comics, Spiderman
By John J. Joex
Many of us stateside may not realize it, but back in 1978 Japan produced a live action Spider-Man television series (not to be confused with the short-lived U.S. live action series on CBS in 1977). Apparently Marvel made a licensing agreement in the late seventies with Toei Company that allowed them to adapt several of their better known comic book characters. The Japanese company started with Spider-Man and produced a 41 episode series that looks something like the web crawler meets Ninjas meets The Power Rangers meets the Shogun Warriors meets Ultraman. As far as costume and powers, the character in this series closely resembles the Marvel version. However, the similarities quickly diverge from there.
This Spider Man has alien origins as he gets his powers from his 400 year old “brother” from the planet Spider (where else?) and must fight the sinister Professor Monster who commands the Iron Cross Army. Along with his customary powers, Spider Man has at his disposal the giant robot “Marveller” (which he pilots Shogun Warrior-style), a cool super-high tech car, and an assortment of other useful little gadgets.
I have only seen the first episode so far, which Marvel has recently begun streaming on their website, but I died laughing throughout the whole thing. Of course it wasn’t intended to be funny, but this show would make great fodder for the MST3K guys. To get an inkling of what to expect, just take a look at a few of the episode titles: “To the Flaming Hell: See the Tears of the Snake Woman”, “The Hero’s Shining Hot Blood”, “From the Unexplored Amazon: Here Comes the Mummified Beautiful Woman”. The Marvel website appears to have quite a number of episodes from the series available for online viewing, though I can’t seem to find a homepage for the show.
It’s all great cheesy fun and definitely worth your time to catch a few of the episodes on the internet. And we can only hope that the series will soon get a full DVD treatment here in the states. This one would be great viewing late at night with a group of friends and plenty of alcoholic beverages.
Countdown to Fall: Does Heroes Suck? Can it Be Fixed? Does Anybody Care Anymore?
August 6, 2009 at 8:04 am | In Articles, John J. Joex | 11 CommentsTags: Heroes
(The Fall season is just around the corner, Vampire Diaries and Supernatural premiere on Sept. 10th, so now is the time to start taking a first look at what is coming.)
By John J. Joex
The Season 4 Premiere of Heroes is just around the corner (September 21st), so now seems like the appropriate time to ask the question: does the show really suck? Really? Well, apparently quite of number of people seem inclined toward that opinion based on the negative buzz I have seen bouncing around the internet this past season. And while Season 3 was running, our stats showed that nearly 30% of the search engine terms that directed people to this site contained the words “Heroes” and “Sucks”. So I would say that the overall opinion on the series does not skew heavily in the positive of late. (Full Article)
Also See:
More from the Golden Age of Radio
July 11, 2009 at 8:00 am | In Articles, Sam Christopher | 1 CommentTags: Audio, Science Fiction Radio
By Sam Christopher
Dimension X“Adventures in time and space, transcribed in future tense… (voice and echo effect) Dimension X”
This precursor to X Minus One (see previous column) only lasted about a year and a half, but it dramatized some great stories during that time from the leading writers of sf in that day. Setting the manner and style for X Minus One, Dimension X gave us great stories like:
“With Folded Hands” by Jack Williamson: In a future where robots, called “mechanicals” here, do virtually all the menial labor for Man, nothing could be better than a new type of mechanical that can do everything for Man, take care of man completely. Or could it? A story that shows the dangers of allowing “Those Who Know Better” to “ensure our safety” by taking all responsibility away couldn’t be more appropriate for this time, and this one really hits the mark squarely.
“Universe” by Robert Heinlein: A “race” of men come to believe the generational space ship they’re on is the entire Universe, and they worship the chief engineer of the project which built the ship generations ago, a man named Jordan, as God. Great drama about the way Man thinks and acts when confronted with truth that conflicts with preconceived notions and belief systems. Besides the obvious statement on religion and blind devotion to traditional thoughts, this story also held a rather pointed statement about race relations, as the mutants—humans changed by living in the upper decks of the ship where the radiation shielding wasn’t so strong—are treated with disdain and hatred by the “normal” humans.
“Report on the Barnhouse Effect” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr.: A college professor discovers a mental discipline that allows him to do anything he chooses through telekinesis, which makes him the most sought after weapon in the Cold War. Kind of a precursor to the original Outer Limits tv episode, “The Man with the Power” starring Donald Pleasance as a college professor with enhanced mental abilities, although that show went in an entirely different direction than was followed here.
“The Embassy” by Martin Pearson (Donald A. Wollheim): A strange, rather eccentric man hires a hardboiled private dick to find the “Martian Embassy” in New York. That’s right, the Martian Embassy; Mr. Graffious (that’s his name) says it’s real and that the Martians are using it as a listening post to gather intelligence for their planned invasion. The detective laughs at the premise but finds the cash offered for the job a much more serious matter. And, of course, he does find the Martian Embassy.
“Nightfall” by Isaac Asimov: This was the final dramatization in the show’s run. If you’re a true sf fan you’ve probably heard the name Isaac Asimov once or twice. This story is generally considered to be one of his three best shorts (the other two being “The Ugly Little Boy” and “The Last Question”) and is probably my second favorite of his (a close second to “The Last Question”). Imagine a world with six suns, a world where it’s never dark, a world where night is just a legend. Except for one time approximately every 2,000 years. Now imagine a people living on that world, and what they might think about the fall of night. Asimov did, and it was fantastic. This is a great dramatization of that story.
I’ve never understood the shortness of this series; it, along with “little sister” X Minus One, is easily the best I’ve heard from anthology science fiction on the radio.
Exploring Tomorrow
This short series only lasted about six months. Hosted by the legendary editor of Astounding Science Fiction Magazine John W. Campbell (who also wrote the great short story, “Who Goes There?”, which was the basis for Howard Hawks’ film Thing From Another World and the even more celebrated John Carpenter remake The Thing), this show provided a moral with its stories. I’ve only heard a few, but a couple favorites:
“Liar” by Isaac Asimov: A short from this master’s celebrated “Robot” series, this was a tale which dramatized the idea of how a robot which could read minds would interpret and implement the author’s famous “Three Laws of Robotics”. The ending here, in which Dr. Susan Calvin uses ruthless logic to bring the story to conclusion, is especially good, though a little heavy-handed.
“The Happiness Effect” by Raymond E. Banks: What if a surgery could be performed on every person that would make them into whatever the rulers of a society deemed was most needed? And the surgery could also be performed in such a way that the citizenry would be happy to have been tampered with? This stars Mason Adams and is probably my favorite from this series of the ones I’ve heard.
Campbell’s delivery of the morals in this series was rather dry, and it seems to me on listening now that it was made for a more adult audience than Dimension X or X Minus One. Still, I have enjoyed the three or four that I’ve heard and will try and listen to more in the future.
Escape
“Tired of the everyday grind? Ever dream of a life of romantic adventure? Want to get away from it all? We offer you… Escape! Escape—designed to free you from the four walls of today for a half-hour of high adventure!”
This anthology series specialized in tales of excitement and adventure (for those who couldn’t tell by the tagline). There were men trapped in the Arctic, men trapped on sinking ships, men searching for gold in the lost jungles or hidden islands of the world. There were also great sf stories dramatized, like:
“Earth Abides” by George R. Stewart: An apocalyptic epic in which the vast majority of the population dies as the result of a disease, this novel was made into a special two-part episode of Escape. In this adaptation, Isherwood Williams is on a hunting trip in the mountains when bitten by a rattlesnake. He recovers and returns to civilization to find there is no more civilization, just a collection of vagabonds and people driven a little mad by the loss of their loved ones and friends. He finds a woman, Emma, and the two marry and have children, founding a colony that, by the end of the story, is a good beginning for a resurgence of humanity. One interesting difference from the novel is that the radio play makes no mention of Emma’s race; in the novel, from what I understand, she’s black. I suppose an interracial relationship was deemed too adventurous by Escape story editors. Still, a very good production.
“Dream of Armageddon” by H.G. Wells: A man dreams of a future which is so real he begins to see it as the reality and his waking life as nothing. Unfortunately, the dream—which he goes into every time he goes to sleep—is set in a time in which tensions are escalating into war, and he and his wife in that time are trapped behind enemy lines. A very sad and frightening story which never lets the listener up for air, with a chilling ending that leaves its audience thinking hard about the nature of reality and our place in it.
“Zero Hour” by Ray Bradbury: My favorite story of Bradbury’s ever adapted to radio, this tells the tale of a child’s game called “Invasion” which is sweeping the country and, perhaps, the world. The story centers on a woman whose little girl is playing the game with her friends outside, a woman who grows more and more uneasy as the day goes on. More and more uneasy as what the kids call “Zero Hour” nears—5 pm that afternoon. We follow the woman through the day and hear her mounting terror as she fears what’s coming more and more and the mystery builds to a satisfying conclusion that is a real attention-getter.
To hear these and other of these great shows, either subscribe to XM/Sirius or go to the Radio Spirits website, where you can order or download to your heart’s delight. Also, many episodes from shows like Dimension X and Exploring Tomorrow are available for free download at OTR.Network Library.
Previous:
Looking Back: Old Time Radio Shows
June 29, 2009 at 7:00 am | In Articles, Reviews, Sam Christopher | 3 CommentsTags: Audio, Science Fiction Radio
By Sam Christopher
Before television supplanted radio as the primary broadcast medium for entertainment, spoken-word dramas and comedies were beamed to the homes of children of all ages across America and overseas for our servicemen and women. Family comedies like Fibber McGee and Molly, Father Knows Best, and The Life of Riley, along with skit comedies like Jack Benny and Abbott and Costello, brought smiles to millions, while westerns like Gunsmoke and The Six-Shooter (which starred Jimmy Stewart) set the stage for the great tv westerns to come. The detective drama was also a well-loved genre for the medium, too, with great shows like Dragnet, Yours Truly, and Johnny Dollar, along with many others bringing mystery and adventure into their listeners’ heads. And, of course, any discussion of the “theater of the mind” would be incomplete without mentioning the great works of speculative fiction presented within it. There are far too many of these shows to do them justice in one column, so here are just a few to start with…
“Who knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men? The Shadow knows! (Evil laugh)”
So began this radio drama about a “superhero” whose main power was a psychic ability to cloud men’s minds so that he became invisible to them. That and an evil ominous laugh that instilled fear in his prey. Beginning as just the narrator of a mystery anthology program in 1930, The Shadow character proved so popular that the series was cancelled in 1935 in order to completely retool the character (along the lines of the pulp fiction magazine that was already in production) and in 1937 he returned as the star of his own show. Orson Welles played The Shadow, as well as The Shadow’s alter ego Lamont Cranston, a wealthy “man about town”. This show also introduced Margo Lane, Cranston’s girlfriend (for want of a better word; their relationship was never clearly defined) and the only person to know The Shadow’s true identity. My two favorites in the roles are Bill Johnstone, who took over from Welles (although Welles does a very good Cranston), and Agnes Moorhead (who was also Samantha’s mother on Bewitched, among many other roles in radio, tv, and film) as Lane. However, the most interesting behind the scenes story I can think of from the series is Welles’. It was his habit to arrive at the studio about five minutes before the broadcast and read the script cold, without ever having seen it before. He said he preferred being surprised by the events of the stories the same way the characters were.
The scripts could be very inventive, too. Criminals were forever trying to trap The Shadow despite his invisibility to them. One forced The Shadow to come at him from across a bay, reasoning that he could see the ripples in the water and find The Shadow that way, and another rigged a door with an electronic sensor to slam shut if anything crossed its threshold. There were dark museums and ghostly ships in the fog, with murderous smugglers and gangland wiseguys: a perfect brew for carrying us through the darkest night for the better part of two decades.
“The weed of crime bears bitter fruit. Crime does not pay! The Shadow knows! (evil laugh)”
“Countdown for blastoff… X minus five… four… three… two… X minus one… fire! (Rocket blasts off as music builds to crescendo) From the far horizons of the unknown comes transcribed tales of new dimensions in time and space. These are stories of the future; adventures in which you’ll live in a million could-be years on a thousand may-be worlds. The National Broadcasting Company, in association with Street and Smith, publishers of Astounding Science Fiction, present… (echo effect) X <x,x,x> Minus <minus, minus, minus> One <one, one, one>!”
One of my absolute favorite sf radio shows, this ran for nearly three years, from April ’55 to January ’58, taking over from the short-lived but also outstanding show Dimension X (see later column). Like its predecessor, this show featured great sf of the day as told by the great sf writers of the day. Among my favorites:
“And the Moon Be Still as Bright”, a piece of the great master Ray Bradbury’s The Martian Chronicles, in which the second Earth expedition to Mars carries a man who comes to see himself as the last Martian.
“The Veldt”, also by Bradbury, which chronicled in grisly fashion the dangers of holodeck technology.
Frederick Pohl’s “Tunnel Under the World”, in which an advertising exec comes up with a unique method of creating the perfect focus group.
Robert Sheckley’s “Skulking Permit”, in which a colony that’s been cut off from Mother Earth for centuries is contacted by the new regime here and figures they better do whatever they have to to fit in. This is a very funny story.
There are many others I could name here, “A Logic Named Joe”, “A Pail of Air”, as well as many others I’ve heard but don’t have the name for off the top of my head. As with any anthology series, of course, some installments were better than others but overall this was an outstanding showcase for sf.
Suspense
“Radio’s outstanding theater of thrills presents… a story well-calculated to keep you in… SUSPENSE!”
Another anthology series, this one focusing not on sf but rather dramatic stories with an air of mystery to them, this show nonetheless boasted some great storytelling in the range of the fantastic. These included adaptation’s of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Curt Siodmak’s great novel Donovan’s Brain, as well as the Lovecraftian short “Black Door”, about an expedition into the hidden world behind a black door found at the bottom of a volcano in a South American jungle. Usually well-written and well-acted, this show nearly always pleased.
Rogue’s Gallery
And the last one for today is a detective show starring Dick Powell, who would go on to the more celebrated role of Richard Diamond, Private Investigator. This is a pretty straight-forward drama about a PI named Richard Rogue, except for the character Eugor, who acts as Rogue’s “alter-enemy” and introduces a fantasy element to the program. Whenever Rogue is knocked unconscious (as he invariably is in every show), he finds himself ascending to “Cloud 8” and is laughed at and hounded by the cackling sprite Eugor (“Rogue” spelled backwards) until being forced back into consciousness by said sprite. A very fun show, imbued with the easy-going, witty charm that Powell brought to everything he did.
That’s it for now, folks. To hear these and other of these great shows, either subscribe to XM/Sirius or go to the Radio Spirits website, where you can order or download to your heart’s delight. Also, many episodes from shows like X Minus One and Suspense are available for free download at OTR.Network Library.
Incongruities of Continuity: Looking at the New Star Trek Movie’s Time Travel Foibles
June 26, 2009 at 7:33 am | In Articles, John J. Joex, Summer of Star Trek | 6 CommentsTags: Star Trek
(Continuing our Summer of Star Trek series)
By John J. Joex
(WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD)
So now that we have had almost two months to let the new Star Trek movie settle in our psyches, I’d say it’s time to take a little bit closer look at what they did with time travel and see just how consistent it was with the temporal logic the franchise has previously established. First, as a quick recap of my original review, I really enjoyed the movie. However, the more I thought about what they did to change the established Star Trek timeline, the more its contrivances annoyed me.
Now those who have followed this site for a while will know that I’m not particularly fond of time travel stories, especially the way such recent shows as Heroes and Lost have used the device. What I hate most about time travel in Science Fiction is that it so often provides writers with a cheap way out of a predicament they have written themselves into and decided they do not like. Did they kill off a character they really want to bring back? Just go back in time and change the past. Did they decide they don’t like the direction that a story is going? Just go back and create an alternate timeline. Or worst yet, have a character from the future go back into the past and do something that causes future events even though those events never would have happened unless they traveled back in the past creating an irritating chicken-and-the-egg endless loop paradox (i.e., Richard mysteriously shows up to provide aid to Locke after he was shot, but he only showed up because time traveling Locke told him to do so because he knew he would do so because of what already happened).
Too often, writers rely on one or all of these tricks, along with others I haven’t even mentioned, in order to leapfrog over having to devote themselves to just telling a good story. And rarely is time travel used as a strong element to tell a good Science Fiction story that makes you think, instead of just making your head hurt if you think too much about it (the recent movie Primer is one of those rare exceptions).
This doesn’t mean that I hate time travel stories in general, I just generally get annoyed because I find them too contrived and they either do not follow the very rules that they ostensibly establish or they just follow no rules at all.
The original Star Trek series actually usually did a good job of adhering to these rules in its time travel stories. The writers incorporated it as a Science Fiction element as opposed to a story contrivance, and usually did not diverge too much from the rules they established.
From TOS, both the episodes “City on the Edge of Forever” and “Tomorrow is Yesterday” show that traveling back in time can change history, but that it was possible to reverse the changes made and set history straight. “Assignment: Earth” may have seemed to diverge from this a bit, but the Enterprise crew intervened because they believed they were stopping Gary Seven from changing the future. In “All Our Yesterdays”, the people of Sarpeidon didn’t seem to care if going in the past changed the future, but then their planet was doomed anyway. Even when you get to the later series episodes that dealt with alternate timelines, like the TNG episode “Yesterday’s Enterprise”, they still had the option to correct the timestream, though the TNG episode “Parallels” did throw us a bit of a curve with the suggestion of multiple parallel universes.
So that leads us to J.J. Abrams movie and what it did with changing the timeline. In this one, Romulan Captain Nero unintentionally changes history when he attacks the USS Kelvin, not realizing that his ship has traveled 150 years into the past. Nero’s actions create an all new timeline that ultimately includes the complete destruction of the planet Vulcan.
Now as a story element to reboot the franchise, I understand why they did what they did. But the established rules in the Star Trek universe dealing with time travel say that even though the past can be changed and create a new timeline, those changes are correctable. The movie, however, seems to imply that the new timeline is fixed and cannot be reversed. So are you telling me that Spock would not try to find a way to go back in time and stop Nero from destroying Vulcan? And if Kirk knew that correcting the timeline would mean that his father would live, are you telling me he wouldn’t give it a try? In previous stories dealing with alterations of the past, the primary characters have always considered it their duty to set things straight. What happened here?
I know, I know, the answer is obvious. The creative team needed a device that allowed them to move the franchise in a new direction while also respecting the existing canon. And on that level, I actually like what they have done. But I wish that they had presented some plausible explanation of why Kirk, Spock, and the others would not try to correct the timeline so that at least the writers could say they attempted to stay within the rules that the franchise had previously established (and perhaps they still will in a future movie). Otherwise the change in the timeline is nothing more than a contrivance that allows the writers to do what they want and somewhat weakens the use of time travel for the franchise going forward.
Don’t get me wrong, I like the left turn that the franchise has taken and I think it opens up endless story possibilities. Still, I have to admit to being annoyed that they did this at the expense of the canon that preceded this movie. Ultimately I am just quibbling over an annoyance, but I do hope that time travel in the Star Trek universe going forward will not become a watered down device that gives writers a cheap out at the expense of good story telling.
What’s New in Online Science Fiction and Fantasy TV?
June 18, 2009 at 8:24 am | In Articles, John J. Joex | Leave a CommentTags: Hulu, Online Viewing, Science Fiction Television, The Listener
By John J. Joex
Run out of things to watch with the 2008-09 season over and the DVD sets from those shows still in pre-order status? Well Hulu.com has added a few new Science Fiction and Fantasy offerings to its ever expanding catalog, and I’m sure between that and the other shows available online you can find something to pique your interest.
Among the new additions to Hulu is the futuristic legal drama Century City. Premiering on CBS in 2004, this one basically give us L.A. Law twenty five years in the future and explores the implications of things like cloning, genetic profiling, and advanced pharmaceuticals. It only ran for nine episodes before CBS pulled the plug on it and I remember tuning in a time or two and finding it somewhat interesting.
Venturing back to the early days of television (when the world apparently was black and white), Hulu has brought us the nascent Science Fiction anthology series Tales of Tomorrow. Among that show’s more notable episodes during its original run were adaptations of Frankenstein starring Lon Chaney, Jr. and 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea starring Thomas Mitchell as Captain Nemo. Hulu currently only has the first season available (which includes the Frankenstein adaptation), but hopefully more will follow.
The big budget Land of the Lost remake may have flopped in theaters, but you can revisit the original series on Hulu. Sure it had cheesy special effects, bad acting, and Holly screaming all the time, but the series was actually quite fun at times and had some decent episodes penned by Science Fiction authors such as Larry Niven, and Ben Bova, and David Gerrold (who also served as the show-runner during its first season). Only Season 1 is currently available, but I am sure more will follow.
Also, NBC’s new Canadian import The Listener is available on Hulu as well. About a telepath who after years of shunning his ability now decides to use it to help people, the series has so far proved mildly interesting (though what’s up with Toby Logan’s 60’s British Invasion haircut?).
Hulu has also recently expanded its episode list for the animated series Exosquad. They now have the full second season available for the “American Anime” that originally ran in the early 90’s. Though annoyingly enough, they are still missing episode 11 of the first season. So if you really want to see that one, you will have to buy the DVD.
In addition to these new offerings, we have updated our Online Sci Fi TV Index to include Hulu’s Anime offerings which we previously only had select listings from. The site has over the past year expanded their selection in this area including such excellent series as Death Note and Mushi-shi and classics like Voltron.
As far as AOL’s In2TV site, it looks like they will not be bringing back many of the offerings they once had available. They previously offered series not available online anyplace else like The Adventures of Brisco County Jr. and Max Headroom, but the site went through some changes which included dropping those shows. Now, most of their offerings are the same as what you will find at the superior Hulu.com. Currently, the only genre offerings from In2TV.com that I do not see on Hulu are Batman: The Animated Adventures and Wonder Woman so we have revised our index to reflect what is currently available on that site.
Stay tuned to this site as we continue to update our index with Science Fiction and Fantasy television available for free online viewing. And if you know shows that we have missed that are available from legitimate sites, Email us at mail@axiomsedge-scifi.com.
For a full list of available shows, visit our Science Fiction and Fantasy Online TV Index
Why Weren’t They Cancelled?
June 12, 2009 at 8:00 am | In Articles, Cancellation Watch, John J. Joex | 2 CommentsTags: Chuck, Dollhouse, Heroes, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
By John J. Joex
Nielsens, Nielsens, Nielsens. They still rule the television world, but maybe, just maybe, this season we have seen a turn of events that could mean that they have dropped a notch or two in significance. Over the last two days, I looked at the shows that were cancelled this past season, now it’s time to consider three shows that received unlikely renewals:
Dollhouse – Against all odds, this show received the greenlight for a second season despite pulling CW-like numbers almost from the beginning of its run. Remember this milestone because it could mark a turning point in the decision making of network executives when they actually start to look beyond the outdated Nielsen ratings system and factor in such things as DVR/Internet viewing and Internet downloads. I even heard rumors that FOX executives took into account future DVD sales when making their decision (and for those who don’t know, Joss Whedon’s previous FOX series Firefly pretty much led the charge in establishing the DVD market as a viable outlet for short-lived series). From what I understand, the network wanted to keep both Dollhouse and The Sarah Connor Chronicles, but they could not justify the expense. So it may very well have come down to a coin toss (or the scenario HijiNKS Ensue postulated), but Dollhouse did have better numbers in DVR viewing and iTunes downloads. Does this renewal really indicate a change in thinking among the networks, or did Joss Whedon just succeed at getting the right FOX exec drunk at the right time? Too early to tell. If Dollhouse keeps up the same numbers next season and still gets renewed for a third season, we will know that we have seen clear signs of change in network thinking (with FOX at least). If it gets the axe, then we will know it was nothing more than a failed experiment.
Chuck and Heroes – Both of these shows languished in the ratings this past season, though Heroes experienced much more of a drop-off from start to finish whereas Chuck started with low numbers and pretty much stayed there all season. But they both had one important thing going for them: they aired on fourth place NBC which could not bring itself to dump two of its highly branded shows. Chuck is a critical darling and has a vocal fanbase that continues to spread good buzz about it across cyberspace (and even if, like me, you are not a hardcore fan of the show, you just can’t hate it). Heroes has definitely lost some goodwill of late with its erratic story-telling, but it still scores well with the highly coveted 18-34 demographic and sponsors are still willing to buy up add-time despite its ratings slump. And with both being seasoned shows, NBC has to be thinking about padding on episodes so that they will have a more attractive syndication package and can sell more DVD sets. Still, despite all of that, there’s no question these shows would have gotten the boot if they resided on FOX, ABC, or CBS (in fact that last network would have given up on them long ago, but don’t get me started . . . ). Going into next season, I think Chuck has the best chance of keeping its run going. As long as it doesn’t slip in the ratings (and as long as NBC continues to struggle), I believe they will keep it around. Heroes, though, faces its last chance to win back fans. After all the up and downs that series has taken us on since completing its stellar first season, fans have little patience with it and many have just given up on it. The series ended its third season with a paltry 6.4 million viewers, a far cry from the 12 to 15 million it used to enjoy. So without a significant upswing in the quality of the scripts that will generate some good buzz to bring fans back, Season 4 will be the show’s last. And if NBC starts to become viable again (unlikely) and actually compete with ABC, CBS, and FOX, Chuck and Heroes both could receive their walking papers if they do not improve their ratings.
See also, Why Were They Cancelled? Part 1 and Part 2
Related Articles:
Johnny Jay’s Network Report Cards Part 1 and Part 2
Johnny Jay’s Report Card on the 2008-09 Season
2008-09 Season Science Fiction and Fantasy TV Awards
Plus, Your Chance to Grade the Networks
Have an idea for an article or review relating to the Science Fiction and Fantasy genre? We are always looking for fresh ideas so write it down and send it to us at mail@axiomsedge-scifi.com. (See our Submissions Guidelines)
Check out the New and Upcoming DVDs, along with specials under $20 and under $10.
2008-09 Season Sci Fi / Fantasy TV Awards
June 11, 2009 at 8:04 am | In Articles, John J. Joex, Polls | Leave a CommentTags: Battlestar Galactica, Dollhouse, Knight Rider, Legend of the Seeker, Lost, Pushing Daisies, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
By John J. Joex
The 2008-09 Season is over, so now its time to look back at the good and the bad that the season brought us. Below are my nominations for Best New and Returning shows, Worst New and Returning shows, Biggest Surprise of the Season, and so on. But don’t just take my word for it, cast your vote as well. (Read the Full Article)
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.





Available at Amazon.com




